SIGN IN YOUR ACCOUNT TO HAVE ACCESS TO DIFFERENT FEATURES

CREATE AN ACCOUNT FORGOT YOUR PASSWORD?

FORGOT YOUR DETAILS?

AAH, WAIT, I REMEMBER NOW!

CREATE ACCOUNT

ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT?

IAHIP

CALL: +353 (0)1 284 1665
  • Contact Us
  • Classifieds
    • Publications
    • Services
    • Training
    • All Ads
    • Submit Ad
  • News
    • IAHIP News
    • Blog
  • Members
    • AGM 2020 & 2019
    • Events Calendar
    • Professional Conduct
    • Continued Professional Development -CPD- For Accredited Psychotherapists
    • Accreditation
    • Re-accreditation
    • Supervision
    • Honorary Membership
    • Child and Adolescent
    • Garda Vetting
    • Resources
      • Members’ Resources
    • Payments
  • SIGN UP
  • LOGIN
  • Home
  • About
    • About IAHIP
    • Governing Body
    • Committees
      • Committees
      • Regional Development
    • Complaints
    • Constitutional Documents
      • Articles of Association
      • Bye-Laws of the Association
    • IAHIP in N.I.
    • Considering a career in psychotherapy?
  • Psychotherapy
    • About Psychotherapy
    • How Psychotherapy Can Help Me
    • Choosing a Psychotherapist
    • Useful Links
  • Join
    • Join IAHIP
    • Why Join IAHIP?
    • Benefits of Membership of IAHIP
    • Categories of Membership
    • Fees
  • Publications
    • Inside Out
    • Subscribe
    • Buy Back Issues
    • Buy Full Page Ad
    • Buy Half Page Ad
    • Advertising
  • Training
    • Recognised Training Courses IAHIP
    • European Certificate of Psychotherapy (ECP)
  • Find a Therapist
  • Home
  • Inside Out
  • Issue 13: Summer 1993
  • BOOK REVIEW: James Hillman: Suicide and the Soul

BOOK REVIEW: James Hillman: Suicide and the Soul

1964, Revised 1976, Spring Books, Texas. ISBN 0 88214 208 9.

The main strength of this thoughtful book lies in its acknowledgement that forms of belief underlie human systems, and naturally, its weakness lies in its allegiance to just one of these. Hillman compares “analysis” (by which he means Jungian Analysis) with medicine and psychiatry, theology and philosophy as systems for approaching the question of suicide and the soul. He comes to the unsurprising conclusion that only Jungian analysis is adequate to the task. However, the journey he makes toward this point is interesting and challenges many of the assumptions therapists would be likely to make about suicide. As he points out early in the book, no question is better calculated to drive one back to beliefs, rather than out into experience. He suggests this reluctance stems from our common attitudes towards death. I think he underestimates the particular horror self-inflicted death or attempted death hold over us. Nonetheless his assertion that “psychology has not paid enough attention to death” is easy to confirm and makes a stimulating starting point for his argument about the function of therapy. My unease stems simply from the fact that he does not seem to distinguish very clearly between self-inflicted and other forms of death.

The major argument of the book is that “whenever treatment directly neglects the experience as such and hastens to reduce or overcome it, something is being done against the soul”. He specifically means that he believes the prevention of suicide to be “against the soul”. However, he is scornful about the different “types” or categories of suicide that have been established, for example by Durkheim in his study of suicide. Hillman’s perspective is contrary to the sociologists’ view that suicide can be seen as a sociological phenomenon. He accuses them of “resisting the disintegrating influence of personality”. But of course , his argument is flawed because if the influence of individual personality can be disintegrating to society, it must also work the other way around and hence to confirm the sociologists’ claim that even suicide can be viewed as a supra-personal and social act. What is lacking in the sociological perspective, and what I think makes it necessary for Hillman to attack it so vehemently, is “mystery”. The whole aim of his argument is to place “analysis” in the context of religious mystery and secrecy. At the end of the book he says: “… the analytical relationship is a secret league and the analytical process is a mystery… (but) the analyst serves Apollo, and he works day and night to clarify and illuminate. He is forced to think hard and speak concisely. However, analysis teaches its practitioners how much of human life is concealed in the unconscious. If the soul is a mystery, explanations will always fall short.”

For Hillman, the therapeutic relationship is essentially a secret. He is prepared to say that the analyst should “take a soul history ” and must be a competent mythographer who will-play the “psychopompos” to the soul in despair. “The person obsessed with suicidal fantasies has not been able to experience death psychologically,” he asserts, so the analyst must enable that experience to be had. At base, this is quite a simple argument for compensatory therapy. The person has “failed to experience death psychologically” and must be enabled to do so to move on in whatever direction. What Hillman never seems to account for is the specific in human experience. He fails to comment upon, perhaps even to notice, the anger, self-hatred, guilt, conflict, etc., that surround thoughts of self-slaughter in many cases. Instead substituting the cure-all notion that souls must experience death psychologically and, I think, almost directing the analysand that way. I began to wonder what drove Mr. Hillman to this allegiance, what had made him decide on this interpretation of a particular behaviour (suicide) to the exclusion of all others? For that is what I felt he was doing. Among theories of suicide, this particular one seems narrower and less based in observation than most.

Mary Montaut

Search Inside Out

Latest from the Blog

Latest News

  • New Trends and Opportunities for Psychotherapy as a Profession – Online Workshop
  • Empathy Counselling & Psychotherapy – Rooms to Rent in Portlaoise

Upcoming Events

Contact Us

The Administrator,
The Irish Association of Humanistic and Integrative Psychotherapy Ltd.
40 Northumberland Avenue,
Dun Laoghaire,
Co. Dublin

Telephone: +353 (0)1 284 1665
Email: admin@iahip.org

Office Hours

9.30am – 4.00pm Monday
9.30am – 5.00pm Tuesday to Friday

Telephone Line Answered
Monday – Friday 9.30am – 1.00pm.

Disclaimer

IAHIP Ltd. cannot be held liable for the services, products or information contained in ads posted on this website.

FIND A THERAPIST

Search in radius 0 miles
  • Contact Details
  • Privacy Statement
  • Code of Ethics for Psychotherapists
  • Company Registration

© 2018 All rights reserved.

TOP
This website uses cookies to enhance your browsing experience. Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.